The brand of modem is not as important as what brand of chip is used
inside a modem. The following are some of the more common brands of chip
found in modems.
Lucent
Lucent modems come in
two varieties, the Win modem and the non-Win modem. The Win modems
have a different set of commands they take from the non-Win modems. It
is generally said that of the different Win modems, the Lucent is the
only one that is really good. They are reliable and upgrades are
freely available from Lucent, and are generally very standard. Lucent
modems support both K56Flex and V.90.
Rockwell
(Conexant)
Like the Lucent, this
modem also comes in the two varieties, Win and non-Win which take
different commands from the other. The Rockwell non-Win modems work
pretty good, but the Win modems do not perform as well as the Lucent
Win Modems and cannot be as easily upgraded. Rockwell Modems support
both K56Flex and V.90. This is the most popular chip that most brand
name modems use. Recently Rockwell changed their modem divisions name
to Conexant.
U.S.
Robotics (3com)
These chips are usually
in U.S. Robotics modems (now owned by 3com), and are also in Telepath
modems on Gateway computers. Only a hand full of other manufacturers
use these chips. You will find these chips in both Win and non-Win
modems, but they all use the same commands. The U.S. Robotics chip
supports both X2 and V.90. They tend to connect quicker than other
modems but are not always as reliable.
PC Tel
This is one of the worst
chips. They only seem to be used on Win Modems and they connect slower
and with less reliability than any of the above chips. They support
both V.90 and K56Flex, but their K56flex implementation is very poor
and works worse than any of the previously mentioned modems.
Unfortunately, because they are so cheap, they have become popular in
many computers, including most Compaq computers. These modems have
also been seen under the name "AMR" before which,
apparently, stands for "Audio Modem Riser", which is a small
card plugged into the motherboard, not in a standard slot.
Motorola
Not all Motorola modems
use the Motorola chip, older Motorola 56k Modems used the Rockwell
chip. These chips are not as bad as PC Tel, but not as good as any of
the other previously mentioned chips. They only seem to be used on Win
Modems. Although the documentation says that they support K56Flex, it
is widely reported that they only properly support V.90. They use the
same commands as the Rockwell Win Modem.
Creative
Labs
Not all Creative Labs
modems use the Creative Labs Chip, many of them use the Rockwell chip.
The Creative chip seems to not work as well as the Rockwell, Lucent or
U.S. Robotics chips. They use commands that are similar to Rockwell's
commands but not the same. They do not support K56Flex and only seem
to be used in Win Modems.
ESS
Haven't been able to
find much information about this chip, only that it seems to be
identical to the Creative Labs chip as far as commands and
compatability, etc. are concerned.
Cirrus
Logic
Couldn't find much
information on this chip either. It doesn't seem to be as good as the
Rockwell, Lucent and U.S. Robotics chips. It uses commands that are
similar to the Rockwell. They also only appear to be used in Win
Modems.
|